You're ready to open your Shopify store, but you keep hearing that the wrong payment gateway can cause checkout failures, hidden fees, or even a blocked account. The core question is simple: Which payment gateway should you activate before you commit to a paid Shopify plan? The answer depends on where you sell, what cards your customers use, and how much you’re willing to pay for transaction fees.
Referral disclosure: Nextpath Solutions may receive a referral fee if you create a Shopify account through these links.
Why the Payment Gateway Decision Belongs in Your Pre‑Launch Checklist
Payment processing is the bridge between a shopper’s intent and the money landing in your bank. If the bridge is weak, you’ll see:
- Abandoned carts because the checkout crashes or shows an unsupported card.
- Unexpected fees that eat into your margins.
- Compliance headaches if the gateway doesn’t support your country’s regulations.
All of these issues can be avoided by confirming the right gateway before you sign up for a Shopify plan or start advertising.
Prerequisites: What You Need Before Comparing Gateways
Gather these items first; they will shape the options you can actually use.
- Business location and legal entity. Shopify Payments is only available in certain countries (e.g., US, Canada, UK, Saudi Arabia). If you’re based elsewhere, you’ll need a third‑party provider.
- Bank account details. Most gateways require a local bank account to receive payouts.
- Product type. High‑risk categories (e.g., supplements, adult products) may be restricted by some providers.
- Estimated monthly sales volume. This helps you compare transaction‑fee tiers.
Once you have these basics, you can move on to the selection process.
Step‑by‑Step Process for Shopify Payment Gateway Selection
1. Verify Shopify Payments eligibility
Visit the official Shopify Payments help page. Check the list of supported countries and the required documentation (business registration, tax ID, etc.). If you qualify, Shopify Payments is usually the simplest choice because it integrates natively, reduces extra app fees, and supports major cards, Apple Pay, and Google Pay.
2. List approved third‑party gateways for your country
If Shopify Payments isn’t available, go to the Third‑party providers page. Note down the gateways that support your country and currency. Common options include PayPal, Stripe, 2Checkout, and local banks’ e‑payment services.
3. Compare transaction fees and monthly costs
Create a simple table (Google Sheets works well) with columns for:
- Setup fee (if any)
- Monthly fee
- Credit‑card fee (e.g., 2.9% + $0.30)
- Alternative‑payment fee (e.g., PayPal)
- Chargeback or dispute fees
Plug in your estimated monthly sales to see the approximate cost for each gateway.
4. Check payout schedule and currency conversion
Some gateways hold funds for 7‑14 days, while others (including Shopify Payments) can release payouts daily. If you sell in multiple currencies, verify whether the gateway offers automatic conversion or if you’ll incur conversion fees.
5. Review technical integration requirements
All Shopify‑approved gateways install via the Payments settings, but a few may need extra apps or custom code. Note any additional monthly app fees and whether you have the technical comfort to configure them.
6. Test the checkout flow in a development store
Before committing to a paid plan, create a free Shopify development store (Shopify Partner account provides this). Enable the shortlisted gateways, place a test order using the sandbox credentials each provider supplies, and verify that the order completes, the payment status updates, and you receive a simulated payout email.
Realistic Hypothetical Example
Scenario: A Pakistani entrepreneur, Aisha, wants to sell handmade leather bags to customers in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates. She plans to launch in three months and expects $5,000 in sales per month.
- Business location: Pakistan (Shopify Payments not available).
- Bank account: A Pakistani bank account in PKR.
- Supported currencies: SAR, AED, USD.
She checks the third‑party list and finds two viable options: PayPal and Stripe (via a local partner). She records the fees:
GatewaySetupMonthlyCard feePayout delay PayPal$0$02.9% + $0.302‑3 days Stripe$0$02.9% + $0.307 daysBoth have similar fees, but PayPal offers instant payouts for a small extra fee, which aligns with her cash‑flow needs. She also notes that Stripe requires a local bank account in the currency of the payout; her Pakistani account would incur conversion fees, so she leans toward PayPal.
After enabling PayPal in a development store and completing a sandbox transaction, the checkout works smoothly. Aisha decides to launch with PayPal as the primary gateway and keep Stripe as a backup for future expansion.
Common Mistakes and How to Fix Them
- Skipping eligibility checks. Result: account suspension. Fix: Verify country support on Shopify’s official pages before enabling a gateway.
- Ignoring currency conversion costs. Result: hidden expenses that shrink profit margins. Fix: Choose a gateway that pays out in your bank’s currency or factor conversion fees into your pricing.
- Relying on a single gateway without a backup. Result: checkout fails if the provider experiences downtime. Fix: Enable a secondary provider (e.g., PayPal alongside Shopify Payments) to provide redundancy.
- Not testing in sandbox mode. Result: surprises at launch like missing required fields. Fix: Always place at least one test order per gateway before going live.
Pre‑Launch Payment Gateway Checklist
- Confirm your business’s legal address and bank account details.
- Check Shopify Payments eligibility for your country.
- List all third‑party gateways supported in your region.
- Gather fee structures (setup, monthly, transaction, chargeback).
- Calculate estimated monthly cost based on projected sales.
- Verify payout schedule and currency conversion terms.
- Set up a free development store and enable each gateway.
- Complete a sandbox test order for every gateway.
- Document any required documentation (tax ID, business registration) for the chosen gateway.
- Plan a backup gateway in case of downtime.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use more than one payment gateway on Shopify?
Yes. Shopify allows multiple providers, and you can set a priority order in the Payments settings.
Do I need a separate merchant account for each gateway?
Most third‑party gateways act as their own merchant account, so you won’t need an additional one. Shopify Payments uses the account you set up during onboarding.
What if my customers use a card not supported by the chosen gateway?
Enable a secondary gateway that accepts a broader range of cards (e.g., PayPal) to capture those sales.
Are there any hidden fees I should watch for?
Watch for currency conversion fees, chargeback fees, and optional features like fraud protection that may add monthly costs.
Conclusion: What to Do Next
Before you click “Start free trial” on Shopify, answer these three questions:
- Is Shopify Payments available for my business location?
- Which third‑party gateway offers the lowest total cost for my expected sales and currency?
- Have I successfully tested the checkout flow in a sandbox environment?
If the answer to any question is “no,” pause the plan sign‑up, gather the missing information, and repeat the steps above. When all three are “yes,” you can confidently select your gateway, start a paid plan, and move toward launch without fearing payment‑related roadblocks.
Should you encounter a requirement you can’t meet—such as a missing local bank account or a high‑risk product restriction—consider consulting a payment‑specialist or exploring a different gateway that supports your niche. The right gateway choice is a foundation; getting it right now saves time, money, and frustration later.